Comparison · last verified September 2026
TickerReplay vs Edgewonk
Edgewonk is known for deep, manual, psychology-focused journaling that many discretionary traders rely on. TickerReplay leans the other way: it automates the trade reconstruction from your fills so journaling starts from accurate, connected trades.
This is manual depth versus automation. Edgewonk rewards traders who enjoy hand-entering and customizing their journal; TickerReplay rebuilds trades from your broker's fills, keeps options whole, and layers notes and tags on top. If manual journaling is the point for you, Edgewonk suits; if you'd rather the trades assemble themselves and then add your notes, TickerReplay does that.
TickerReplay vs Edgewonk at a glance
| TickerReplay | Edgewonk | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Yes: 30 trades per rolling 30 days, full reports and export | No |
| Paid plans | $15 / $30 per month, billed annually | $197 for 16 months (no monthly) |
| Free trial | 7-day trial on paid plans (card required), plus a full free plan | No trial; 14-day money-back |
| Broker sync and import | Yes: 20+ brokerages, plus free CSV import | Yes: 200+ brokers |
| Options as structures | Yes: spreads, condors, rolls, and assignments import as one connected trade | Listed as a supported market; multi-leg not detailed |
| Asset classes | Stocks and options | Forex, stocks, futures, crypto, options, indices, commodities |
| Platform | Web app | Cloud/browser (phone, tablet, or computer) |
The Edgewonk column reflects their public pricing and features page as of September 2026 (source). Prices, promos, and features change; verify on their site before deciding.
Where TickerReplay is different
Options import as structures, not stitched-together rows. A four-leg iron condor is one trade; rolls stay linked as a chain with running credit; an assignment closes the option and opens the stock, connected. Every report is reconstructed from your own executions, with no live market feed. Paid plans start at $15/mo billed annually, and you can export every trade, execution, note, and tag as CSV or JSON on any plan.
Who should pick which
Pick Edgewonk if you journal manually by choice and want deep, customizable psychological tracking.
Pick TickerReplay if you trade options as defined-risk structures, want every metric traceable to your own fills, and prefer a post-trade journal at a lower price.
Common questions
I journal manually in Edgewonk. Is TickerReplay too automated?
TickerReplay rebuilds trades from your fills so you start from accurate, connected trades, then you add notes, tags, and screenshots on top. You still journal; you just don't hand-assemble the trades. If manual entry is the practice you value, Edgewonk leans into that more.
Can I bring my Edgewonk data over?
Yes, via CSV import.
Does TickerReplay do psychology tracking?
It supports notes, tags, and custom classification per trade, and reports slice by tag. Edgewonk is known for deeper, more customizable psychological tracking; if that is central to you, weigh it directly.
We write these from hands-on use of TickerReplay (the screenshots above are our own product) and Edgewonk's public information as of September 2026. Features and pricing change; check Edgewonk's current site before deciding, and if we've got something wrong, tell us at support@tickerreplay.com. SES Technology Ventures LLC.